Wisdom in HR: Navigating Complexities with Clarity and Insight

This is part 4 of a 4 part series on applying the Cardinal Virtues to our craft as HR professionals, or any professional. To read the introduction, click here, and to read parts 1, 2, and 3 click here, here, and here.

“We are not what we know but what we are willing to learn.” – Mary Catherine Bateson

Many of us as children probably looked up to our elders with a hushed awe. They know so much about a great many things. Then we enter our pre-teen and teen years and believe we know so much about a great many things. And then we enter our mid-life years and realize we don’t know as much as we think we know. And then we become elders ourselves, and we know we don’t know much about anything.

Well, that’s the ideal cycle of knowledge, right? We don’t know much. We learn and think we know everything, to finally realizing we don’t know much of anything after all.

Wisdom. This is the ability to realize what we do know, what we don’t know, and what to do about it. It’s not necessarily related to age. Obviously, elders are more likely to have wisdom due to experience, but it’s not a guarantee. Many of us have met a young person who we think “has wisdom beyond their years.”

Wisdom is the fourth and arguably the most integrative of the Stoic cardinal virtues. It enables us to understand the world clearly and make sound decisions based on both knowledge and experience. For HR professionals, wisdom is the guiding light that informs every decision, interaction, and policy we implement. It’s more than just having knowledge of HR practices – it’s about applying that knowledge in a way that benefits both the organization and its people.

In HR, wisdom is what enables us to navigate complex situations where there are no easy answers. It’s the virtue that allows us to balance the needs of employees with those of the organization, resolve conflicts, and make decisions that promote long-term success.

Defining Wisdom in HR

So, wisdom is the ability to judge what is good and bad, and what to do and not to do. IN the context of HR, wisdom looks like:

• Discernment: The ability to assess situations, understand their nuances, and make thoughtful, informed decisions.
• Learning from Experience: Recognizing patterns from past experiences and applying those lessons to new challenges.
• Balancing Competing Needs: Ensuring that the needs of the organization and its people are harmonized, even when they seem at odds.

Wisdom in Practice: Real-World Examples in HR

Wisdom manifests itself in HR every day, from the smallest decisions to the most strategic initiatives. Here are a few real-world examples that highlight how wisdom shapes effective HR leadership:

Example 1: Navigating Employee Conflict with Compassion and Fairness

“Wisdom is knowing what is within your power and what is beyond it.” – Epictetus

Discernment is central to wisdom.

One of the most common challenges in HR is resolving conflicts between employees. In such situations, wisdom requires the ability to listen to all sides, gather facts, and understand the emotional undercurrents before making any decisions. It’s not enough to apply a blanket policy or take a side; a wise HR leader must discern the root cause of the conflict and address it in a way that is fair, just, and compassionate.

I recall a situation where two high-performing team members were in constant disagreement. Their unresolved conflict was impacting team morale and productivity. Rather than jumping to conclusions or issuing directives, I took time to meet with both individuals separately, understanding their perspectives, frustrations, and goals. What emerged was a deeper, underlying issue regarding unclear roles and responsibilities. Instead of taking disciplinary action, I facilitated a team-wide discussion about role clarity, communication channels, and building self-understanding as a precursor for understanding others.

This process has worked well over my years. It doesn’t mean it’s easy. Conflict is rarely easy, but it’s necessary to move forward. There is no movement without friction.

Example 2: Balancing Short-Term vs. Long-Term Solutions in Workforce Planning

“Wisdom is knowing what is within your power and what is beyond it.” – Epictetus

Discernment is central to wisdom.

In such, workforce planning is another area where HR professionals must apply wisdom. It’s easy to focus on immediate staffing needs, but a wise HR leader considers the long-term implications of every hire, promotion, or organizational change.

During a one-time project, I was tasked with hiring several new positions during a period of rapid growth. The pressure to fill these roles quickly was intense, but I knew that hiring the wrong people for the sake of speed would create long-term issues, including higher turnover and cultural misalignment. Instead of focusing solely on immediate needs, I took a more strategic approach, investing in a diverse recruitment strategy that included behavioral assessments, cultural evaluations, and structured interviewing. Did I make all the right hires? I think we rarely do. But, did I make many more correct hires than poor ones? I believe I did! The process, worked, as overall, the hiring lead to sustained growth and greater support for the clients we were serving.

How’d I get there? Research. Reading. Writing. All of these areas helped me write better questions, read into candidate answers better, and form a more complete assessment if the person would succeed or fail when brought on board. Overall, I used the skills allotted to me, and made them work for the project at hand. Sounds rudimentary, but I think wisdom is leaning into what we do well, focusing our strengths on the end goal.

Example 3: Using Data to Inform Decisions

“To wish to be well is a part of becoming well.” – Seneca

Wisdom sees the power in aligning thought and action.

Data-driven decision-making is a hallmark of wisdom in modern HR. Rather than relying solely on intuition, wise HR professionals use data to back up their decisions, especially in areas like compensation, diversity and equity, or performance management.  

In a prior organization, we had issues with diversity. I looked at the internal demographics and compared to the external market. The numbers didn’t match up as they should have. In any customer service situation, and especially in social service nonprofits, we can provide better support when our employees look and can relate to the clientele. I strongly believed that diverse candidates were there, we just were not reaching them.

In response, I implemented a strategy to diversify our workforce. I began targeted ad campaigns and reached out directly to community partners to get the word out. Within a year, workforce representation increased by 15%. Overall, employee engagement improved, particularly among underrepresented groups, and data showed our clients satisfaction increased. These were excellent business results, despite the initial goal simply being focused on doing the right thing (justice) but using a data driven approach (wisdom). This data-driven approach boosted both equity and trust in the organization.

The Role of Wisdom in Tough Decision-Making

Wisdom is especially important in HR when it comes to making tough decisions – those that affect people’s livelihoods, careers, and well-being. Wise HR leaders don’t just follow the letter of the law or policy; they take a holistic view of each situation, considering the emotional, ethical, and long-term consequences.

Example 4: Handling Difficult Terminations with Dignity

Terminations are some of the hardest situations HR professionals have to make recommendation on. A wise HR leader approaches this process with empathy, fairness, and respect, understanding that while the decision might be necessary, it impacts not only the employee being terminated but also the broader organization.

In all situations, it has to be made clear that HR does not make termination decisions. We provide advice and guidance for those who must make these decisions. With that in mind, we need to remember to coach all managers to take care and proceed with empathy. I once had to help guide the termination of a well-liked employee due to continued underperformance. We didn’t begin with termination. We provided every opportunity to get better. We provided resources, guidance, and coaching in clear terms. While the performance issues were well-documented, and the decision was necessary, I knew it was important for the organization to handle the termination with dignity. I coached the manager to approach the conversation with compassion, providing the employee with clear feedback, a fair severance package, and outplacement support. By doing so, I believe we maintained the employee’s dignity and minimized the impact on team morale, while also ensuring that the organization did what it needed to do.

Practical Steps to Apply Wisdom in HR

“By three methods we may learn wisdom: First, by reflection, which is noblest; Second, by imitation, which is easiest; and Third, by experience, which is the bitterest.” –Confucious

HR professionals can cultivate wisdom by being intentional about how they approach their work, continuously learning, and seeking balance in every decision. Here are some practical tips for applying wisdom in HR:

• Listen Before You Act: Take the time to gather information from multiple sources before making decisions, especially in complex or emotional situations. Wisdom comes from understanding all sides of an issue.
• Learn from Mistakes: Mistakes are inevitable, but wise HR professionals learn from them. Reflect on past experiences and use those lessons to improve future decisions.
  – Use Data, But Don’t Ignore Intuition: Data is invaluable, but wisdom also means trusting your instincts and understanding the human side of every decision. Balance quantitative data with qualitative insights.
• Think Long-Term: Always consider the long-term impact of your decisions, especially when it comes to hiring, compensation, or organizational change. Short-term solutions often lead to long-term problems if not considered carefully.
• Stay Curious: Wisdom grows through continuous learning. Stay up-to-date on HR trends, but also seek wisdom from outside your profession. Philosophy, history, psychology, and other fields can offer valuable insights into human behavior and leadership.

The Interplay of Wisdom with Other Virtues

Wisdom, in Stoic philosophy, is the virtue that informs and guides the other three cardinal virtues—courage, temperance, and justice. In HR, this means that wisdom allows us to act courageously when necessary, apply temperance in difficult situations, and promote justice through fair and equitable decision-making. Wisdom ensures that our actions are not reactive, but thoughtful and aligned with a greater purpose.

For example, when an HR leader faces a situation that requires courage—such as addressing a discriminatory practice—wisdom helps ensure that the action taken is not only bold but also informed by experience, data, and ethical considerations. When dealing with a disciplinary issue, wisdom allows us to apply temperance, ensuring that the response is proportionate and fair. And in matters of justice, wisdom ensures that fairness is applied consistently and thoughtfully, always with the bigger picture in mind.

What Wisdom Can Lead Us to Be
Wisdom is the cornerstone of an effective philosopher and informs amazing HR leadership. As a philosopher, wisdom allows us to know the world around us. As an HR professional, wisdom allows us to navigate the complexities of human behavior, organizational dynamics, and business needs with clarity, compassion, and insight. By cultivating wisdom, HR professionals can make decisions that benefit both the individual and the organization, create fair and equitable workplaces, and ultimately, lead with integrity.

In the fast-paced and often emotionally charged world of HR, wisdom is not a luxury—it’s a necessity. It’s what enables us to rise above immediate challenges and see the broader perspective, ensuring that every decision we make contributes to the long-term success of both the people and the organizations we serve.

When you’re sowing the seeds of justice in your life, remember:

• Wisdom in HR means applying knowledge and experience thoughtfully: It helps HR professionals navigate complex situations and make sound decisions.
• Listening before acting is key: Wise HR leaders take time to understand all sides before making decisions.
• Data and intuition work together: Wisdom balances the use of data with an understanding of the human element.
• Learning from past experiences strengthens future decisions: Mistakes are opportunities to gain wisdom.
• Thinking long-term ensures sustainability: Wise decisions consider both immediate and future impacts on the organization and its people.

“Life is very short and anxious for those who forget the past, neglect the present, and fear the future.” – Seneca

© 2024 HR Philosopher. All rights reserved.